Versions of Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application on LawServer 2024 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2022 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2021 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2020 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2019 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2018 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2016 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2015 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2015 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2014 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2013 Alabama Code 12-21-12. Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application 2010 Alabama Code 12-21-12 – Proof by substantial evidence required; scintilla rule abolished; higher standard of proof; substantial evidence defined; application